Proudly Serving Our Community for Over 130 Years as a Nonprofit Leader in Education and Workforce Development.
The 2026 Thrift Trail
We’re so excited to introduce the Inaugural 2026 Thrift Trail —
where every purchase does GOOD.
This isn’t just a thrift trail trip — it’s a feel-good experience with purpose!
This community-powered adventure connects you to local, mission-based thrift stores that make a difference right here in our Valley and beyond.
Every participating thrift shop has one common mission:
They ALL give back to the community in some way!
So when you join the trail, you’re not only discovering unique treasures — you’re supporting businesses that help others, create opportunities, and spread GOOD throughout our community.
🚙 Get Your Map
When you make a donation of $25 or more to Youngstown Area Goodwill Industries, we’ll send you your official Thrift Trail Map! It’s your guide to all the amazing thrift and consignment shops participating across the Valley—start your adventure today!
You can donate on Zeffy, our fundraising platform, below and we will mail you your map or stop into the Youngstown Area Goodwill Office (2747 Belmont Avenue, Youngstown, Ohio) Monday- Friday 8AM-4PM to purchase and pick up your map.
Maps will be mailed out beginning the week of December 8th. 💙
Quantities are limited.
🤝Meet the Thrifts with a Mission
Angels Mission • Menagerie • The Way Station •
St. Vincent de Paul • Penny Pinchers •
VO Depot • Habitat ReStore • The Salvation Army
Angels Missions
4527 Market Street
Youngstown, OH 44512
Hours:
Tuesday through Saturday
11am -5pm
We are committed to helping our community in every way we can. We provide clothing to families and students in need and donate to various organizations. Our outreach extends beyond our local area—we’ve sent clothing to people in need through the Appalachian Project in Kentucky, as well as to communities in Guatemala, El Salvador, Venezuela, the Dominican Republic, and Puerto Rico.
We support Hispanic communities by helping them find jobs and offering translation services for essential needs such as banks, courts, utility companies, medical offices, schools, police departments, and more. We assist with resolving disputes between tenants and landlords and provide guidance in navigating community resources.
Our efforts also include creating access to basic necessities like bathrooms, wells, and electricity in underserved areas. We deliver clothing, medicine, school supplies, shoes, office supplies, and more to those who need them most.
Beyond physical needs, we share the message that God loves everyone and help guide individuals to churches in our community, whether English- or Spanish-speaking. This is the heart of what we do.
The Menagerie
6000 Youngstown-Warren Rd
Suite G
Niles, Ohio 44446
Hours:
Tuesday - Saturday 10-5pm
Our thrift store is a community-powered shop with a big heart! We run entirely on 100% community donations, which means every item on our shelves has been generously given by neighbors who want to make a difference. From clothing and home décor to books, furniture, and one-of-a-kind treasures, our inventory is always changing and full of surprises.
We are a thrift store that helps with funding to support the Animal Welfare League of Trumbull County in their mission to RESCUE, REHABILITATE, ADOPT, EDUCATE.
Website: The Menagerie
The Way Station Thrift Store of Columbiana
769 Springfield Road, Columbiana OH 44408
Hours: M-F 10-4
The Way Station Thrift Store of East Palestine
109 W Rebecca St., East Palestine OH 44413
Hours: M-F 10-4
330-888-9814
The Way Station Thrift Store of East Liverpool
Hours: M-F 10-4
Website: TheWayStationInc.org
The Way Station Thrift Store is an open to the public thrift store offering new and like new clothing, household items, home decor and furniture. We are also a resource for families and individuals in need.
The Way Station is a faith-based nonprofit supporting families and individuals in need. All of our programs in job training, budgeting and more are offered at no cost.
The Thrift Store & Donation Center at the Society of St. Vincent de Paul Mahoning District Council, Inc.
7392 Market St.
Boardman, OH 44512
Hours: Mon.-Sat. 10am-8pm and Sundays Noon-5pm
The Thrift Store & Donation Center at the Society of St. Vincent de Paul Mahoning District Council, Inc. provides donated gently-used, refreshed, and factory-fresh items to all of our customers around the Mahoning Valley, and the proceeds raised directly benefit the charitable work of the Society of St. Vincent de Paul right here in the Valley through the store as well as our Food Pantry, Dining Hall, and Outreach Events. Every dollar saved with us saves so MUCH more than customers may realize!
Opened in 2024, and expanded in 2025 with a dedicated, 5,000 square-foot Furniture Room (the largest in our Valley!), the all-new 21,000+ square-foot Thrift Store & Donation Center boasts a large array of affordably-priced finds and treasures conveniently located near one of the most popular shopping destinations in the area.
Customers can expect to find a large selection of clothing, furniture, toys, decor, jewelry, books, media, kitchenware, factory-fresh mattresses, games, and much more including many sales and discounts that change every week!
The Thrift Store & Donation Center at the Society of St. Vincent de Paul Trumbull County
540 Main Ave SW
Warren OH 44483
Hours:
M-F, 9am-5pm, Sat. 10am-5pm
For over 95 years, the St. Vincent de Paul Society has been a vital partner in Trumbull County, offering safety-net services to the community's most vulnerable residents.
The SVdP Thrift & Furniture Store has been situated in the downtown Warren business community since 1964. Offering high-quality, low-cost home goods, clothing, designer items, furniture, appliances, and factory-fresh mattresses, every shopping trip is a new adventure!
With more than 10,000 square feet of showroom space, you can be sure that our store is organized, clean, and well-stocked. You can also rest assured that you will be assisted by our friendly SVdP staff and volunteers, who all reflect our SVdP pledge to treat everyone with dignity and respect. Come in and find out what all the buzz is about...and feel great about shopping with us because 100% of store proceeds are dedicated to funding local SVdP programs and services.
At the Trumbull County St. Vincent de Paul Thrift and Furniture store, the power of charity is alive in every donation dropped off and every purchase made, one gently used coat can keep a neighbor warm.
Our store is more than just a place to find a bargain; it's a social enterprise with a mission. Whether you donate or shop, you're creating critical local jobs, supporting area families in need, and providing essential resources for individuals and families working to become self-sufficient.
It only takes one person to make a difference…YOU! Your donated items or in-store purchases help transform lives, preserve dignity, and strengthen our community from the ground up.
We invite you to shop with purpose and give with heart!
Penny Pinchers Consignment Store
6826 Market Street
Boardman, Ohio 44512
Hours:
10am - 5pm Monday -Saturday
Penny Pinchers is a non-profit consignment shop benefiting local charities since 1962. We offer new and gently used items. Woman and Men's clothing with accessories. Purses, Jewelry, shoes, and a Household area with antique's, home decor, kitchen items and more! We accept consignments at a 40/60 split and take donations! 100% of donated items go towards our charities.
Penny Pinchers has been a 501-c3 non-profit organization since 1962. Currently, we support The Silver Lining Cancer Fund www.silverliningfund.org and our local Dress to Succeed program.
VO Depot
Veterans Outreach
17 Colonial Drive
Youngstown, OH 44505
Hours:
Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Saturday 10am - 4pm
VO Depot is full of interesting items from clothing to collectibles, antiques to small appliances, furniture and decorations, and even more. It is displayed in a warm and inviting environment. It is located inside the Veterans' Outreach building where they help hundreds of veterans each week with financial assistance, food, clothing, and household needs. The staff are 90% volunteers that give so much of their time and talent to the VO Depot because the funds raised benefit the financial assistance Veterans' Outreach provides veterans.
Veterans get 20% off every day. This is truly shopping with a purpose.
Veterans' Outreach mission is to serve and honor veterans. Each veteran has unique needs, and Veterans' Outreach strives to meet the most urgent needs which could be shelter, rent, utilities, home or auto repairs, insurances, medical needs, groceries, and gas.
Veterans' Outreach hosts the Freedom Food Pantry which serves an average of 150 veterans each week with a box of staple foods. Volunteers man the pantry and serve each veteran with appreciation and a smile.
The VO Depot is not just a thrift store, but it also serves veterans in need. When a veteran is in need of items in the store, but unable to purchase, a voucher is given and the veteran shops for the items needed for free.
Hundreds of veterans have benefitted from the Voucher Program through receiving clothing, cold weather gear, kitchen items, linens, furniture, and appliances.
Habitat for Humanity of Mahoning Valley ReStore
480 Youngstown Poland Rd Struthers, OH 44471
Hours: Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday 9-5, Saturday 9-4
330-755-2232 ext. 106
Discover incredible deals and make a difference! Habitat for Humanity ReStores are nonprofit home improvement stores where you’ll find new and gently used furniture, appliances, building materials, and home décor at a fraction of retail prices.
Our Struthers ReStore helps build homes, community, and hope right here in the Mahoning Valley — serving Mahoning, Trumbull, and Columbiana Counties. 💙🏡
Shop. Donate. Impact your community.
-
Funds local homebuilding
-
Provides affordable home goods
-
Reduces waste in our community
-
Gives donors a meaningful way to give back
-
Creates volunteer opportunities
Discover thousands of name-brand treasures at discounted prices. Every item you take home helps fund The Salvation Army’s drug and alcohol rehabilitation program.
The Salvation Army
444 Boardman-Canfield Rd
Youngstown, OH 44512
Hours: 10-6
The Corner Store
110 N. Market Street
East Palestine, OH 44413
Hours:
Tuesday-Saturday 9-4
Owned and operated by Threshold Residential Services, the Corner Store’s proceeds directly benefit the individuals we serve. The Corner Store is just part of many opportunities that Threshold provides as a site for their vocational training program for individuals with developmental disabilities.
The Corner Store offers a collection of items at half or even a quarter of the cost you’d pay at a regular department store! We have items ranging from small furniture, cookware, toys, and home goods!
We have partnered with Alleycat Charities and Columbiana County Humane Society who provide all their own items for sale in the store. The proceeds from those items are forwarded directly to Alleycat Charities and the Columbiana County Humane Society.
Know of a mission-based thrift store that may want to join the Thrift Trail next year?
Let us know!
🎉 Grand Prize: Over $500 in local treasures!
Winner will be drawn Tuesday, April 7th!
🧭 How to Travel the Trail
1️⃣Donate & Get Your Map
When you make a donation of $25 or more to Youngstown Area Goodwill Industries, we’ll send you your official Thrift Trail Map! It’s your guide to all the amazing thrift and consignment shops participating across the Valley—start your adventure today!
Donate through the Zeffy on this page and we’ll send your map right to your mailbox! Prefer to pick it up in person? Stop by the Youngstown Area Goodwill Office at 2747 Belmont Avenue, Youngstown, Ohio, Monday–Friday between 8 AM and 4 PM to purchase and grab your map. We’d love to see you!
2️⃣ Hit the Trail
Visit each shop between January 12 – March 31, 2026. Every store is offering something special just for trail travelers — whether it’s a discount, freebie, or other surprise perks!
3️⃣ Collect Your Trail Marks
At each participating shop, ask a team member for their official Trail Mark and add it to your map. Keep collecting Trail Marks at every stop until your map is complete!
4️⃣ Turn In Your Completed Map
Once you've collected all your trail marks, mail your map back to the Youngstown Area Goodwill Office (2747 Belmont Ave. Youngstown, Ohio 44505) or drop it off in person (Mon-Fri 8am-4pm) by Friday, April 3rd—and you’ll be in the running for our grand prize drawing!